Why we're here

We believe everyday people deserve a real voice in the decisions that shape their lives. Maybe you're concerned about the cost of living, a decision at your child's school, or an experience with a government agency. Those concerns deserve more than slogans. They deserve an honest hearing and a chance to work toward something better.

That's what the National Coalition hopes to make possible: people coming together to ask questions, compare evidence, learn from each other, and pursue responsible reform. The Constitution and Bill of Rights guide us, including individual liberty, the limits of government power, and the responsibilities of federal, state, and local institutions.

You don't have to agree with every Coalition position to contribute. We welcome respectful criticism, different experiences, and good-faith debate. We don't welcome threats, racist abuse, or harassment. You can read our civic principles and how you can publish and participate.

Our mission, in everyday language

We want to defend constitutional government while helping citizens find practical ways to improve public life. That means understanding the facts, asking which level of government can act lawfully, listening to people affected by a proposal, and being honest about trade-offs.

Here are twelve areas where we believe people can make a difference. Each is a starting point for learning, discussion, and responsible action—not a claim that we've already found every answer.

1. The Economy and Affordability

Why it matters: A functioning market economy depends on stable prices, access to credit, and broad-based opportunity. Persistent cost pressures on housing, energy, food and essentials reduce real wages and household security.
Constitutional anchor: Congress’s power to regulate interstate commerce and provide for the general welfare, Art. I Sec. 8.
What citizens need to do: Track household budget impacts, engage local and state elected officials on zoning, permitting and housing supply, support transparent fiscal reporting, and participate in community economic development boards.

What this could look like: A family facing higher rent might compare local housing costs and ask officials about zoning, permits, and budget priorities.

2. Health and Healthcare

Why it matters: Health security is a core concern for families and workforce participation. Rising premiums, deductibles and administrative complexity limit access and choice.
Constitutional anchor: Police powers for public health are reserved to the states under the 10th Amendment; federal involvement is limited to enumerated powers.
What citizens need to do: Demand price transparency from providers and insurers, support state-level health care policy experimentation, participate in public comment periods for federal and state health regulations, and advocate for patient choice and competition.

What this could look like: Someone trying to understand a medical bill could share that experience and help others compare publicly available prices and coverage rules.

3. Public Education Reform

Why it matters: Education is primarily a state and local responsibility. Outcomes vary widely by district, affecting equity and economic mobility.
Constitutional anchor: No federal constitutional right to a particular education system; education policy is governed by state constitutions and local control.
What citizens need to do: Attend school board meetings, exercise the right to petition under the First Amendment, support parental involvement policies, and hold elected school officials accountable for curriculum transparency and fiscal stewardship.

What this could look like: Parents, teachers, and students might review a school-board proposal together, ask for the underlying evidence, and speak during public comment.

4. Justice Reform

Why it matters: Equal protection under the 14th Amendment and due process under the 5th and 14th Amendments require fair, transparent, and accountable criminal and civil justice systems.
What citizens need to do: Support independent oversight of law enforcement, advocate for sentencing consistency and rehabilitation programs at the state level, participate in grand jury and jury service, and demand public reporting of justice system data.

What this could look like: Residents concerned about fairness in policing or sentencing could examine public reports, ask about oversight, and listen to people with different experiences.

5. Political Term Limits

Why it matters: Concerns about entrenched incumbency and the influence of career politics drive interest in term limits. The Constitution sets qualifications for federal office in Art. I Sec. 2, 3 and Art. II Sec. 1.
Constitutional anchor: Term limits for Congress would require a constitutional amendment under Art. V. States may impose term limits on their own legislators.
What citizens need to do: Advocate for state-level term limit initiatives where permitted, support amendment processes at the federal level, and support campaign finance transparency and anti-corruption enforcement.

What this could look like: Members could weigh the arguments for and against term limits, learn what has happened in states, and discuss the constitutional amendment process for Congress.

6. Tax Relief

Why it matters: Tax burden affects savings, investment and small business formation. Citizens have a constitutional right to be taxed only by representatives under Art. I Sec. 8.
What citizens need to do: Participate in state and federal tax policy hearings, support simplified tax code proposals, monitor state legislature tax votes, and use the right to petition for relief from regressive local levies.

What this could look like: Neighbors might read a proposed local tax change, ask how its revenue would be used, and compare its impact on households and small businesses.

7. National Food and Agriculture Security

Why it matters: Domestic food production, supply chains and rural economies are essential to national security and price stability. The federal government has authority over interstate commerce and agricultural policy.
What citizens need to do: Support policies that preserve farmland and reduce regulatory barriers to production, engage with USDA and state agriculture departments on conservation and market programs, and advocate for supply chain resilience.

What this could look like: Local farmers, shoppers, and small businesses could discuss food costs, farmland preservation, transportation, and the resilience of supply chains.

8. Pharmaceutical Pricing and Profit Limits

Why it matters: High prescription drug prices affect affordability and access. The federal government regulates drug approval and can use purchasing power under its spending authority.
What citizens need to do: Demand transparency in drug pricing, support competition and generic drug policies, engage in FDA and CMS public dockets, and advocate for state pharmacy benefit manager reform.

What this could look like: Members could compare documented prescription prices, ask how pharmacy-benefit arrangements work, and examine proposals for transparency and competition.

9. Bureaucratic Abuse and Overreach

Why it matters: The Administrative State raises questions of separation of powers and due process. The Constitution vests legislative power in Congress, executive power in the President, and judicial power in the courts.
What citizens need to do: Use the Administrative Procedure Act comment process, support legislative oversight of agencies, file petitions for regulatory reconsideration, and support judicial review of agency actions.

What this could look like: A resident struggling to understand an agency decision might ask how to obtain records, request an explanation, or use a lawful appeal process.

10. Immigration Systems

Why it matters: Immigration is an enumerated federal power under Art. I Sec. 8. The nation has a sovereign interest in border security, lawful admission, and the integration of newcomers into the civic life of the states.
What citizens need to do: Engage with Congress on comprehensive immigration reform that respects due process under the 5th and 14th Amendments, support state and local cooperation with federal authorities, and promote civic education programs for lawful residents and citizens.

What this could look like: People affected by immigration policy could compare proposed procedures, discuss border administration and due process, and hear one another without dehumanizing anyone.

11. Labor Institutions and Accountable Worker Representation

Why it matters: Fair and productive workplaces depend on employees who understand their rights, employers who can operate under clear rules, and labor institutions that are transparent and accountable to the workers they represent. Safety, workforce training, effective bargaining, and voluntary worker choice should be evaluated together.
Constitutional and statutory framework: The First Amendment safeguards speech, peaceful assembly and petition against government interference. The National Labor Relations Act separately provides specified organizing and collective-bargaining rights for covered private-sector employees; the Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act establishes governance protections for many labor organizations. Coverage and exceptions matter.
What citizens need to do: Learn which laws apply to their workplaces, examine evidence about worker safety and job opportunity, support fair and transparent labor-management procedures, review union-member rights and financial disclosures where applicable, and participate in lawful public comment and community workforce initiatives. Explore Labor Institutions research.

What this could look like: Workers and employers might compare workplace rules, training opportunities, safety concerns, and whether representation institutions are accountable.

12. Americans with Disabilities and Equal Civic Participation

Why it matters: Americans with disabilities are entitled to dignity, meaningful opportunity, and participation in work, public services, education, elections and community life. Barriers can limit individual choice and keep communities from benefiting from people's skills and contributions.
Constitutional and statutory framework: Due process and equal protection principles provide important constitutional context; the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act set specific federal nondiscrimination and accessibility duties for covered entities. Requirements vary by program, employer, and jurisdiction.
What citizens need to do: Include disabled residents in decisions that affect them, identify inaccessible public services and voting facilities, encourage accessible digital communication, learn about lawful workplace accommodations, and evaluate reforms using direct lived experience, primary legal sources and evidence of outcomes. Explore Americans with Disabilities research.

What this could look like: Members with disabilities could show how a meeting room, website, or voting location creates barriers—and help design a practical improvement.

We affirm that all advocacy is to be conducted peacefully and lawfully, in accordance with the First Amendment rights to speech, petition and assembly, and with respect for the constitutional rights of all persons.

Research note: The sources and search terms below are a starting point for evaluating reform proposals, not citations establishing any specific claim. Policy work should rely on current primary documents, reliable data, transparent methodology, and consideration of credible counterarguments.

Research Guide: Evidence and Sources

1. The Economy and Affordability

Constitutional anchor: Art. I Sec. 8 Commerce Clause, General Welfare Clause
Search tags for evidence:

  • Bureau of Labor Statistics CPI inflation housing energy food 2020-2024
  • Census Bureau Household Pulse Survey cost burden housing
  • Federal Reserve Beige Book consumer affordability
  • Congressional Budget Office household income distribution

Suggested sources: BLS.gov, Census.gov, FRED.stlouisfed.org, CBO.gov

2. Health and Healthcare

Constitutional anchor: 10th Amendment police powers; federal spending power
Search tags for evidence:

  • CMS National Health Expenditure Accounts premiums deductibles
  • KFF Kaiser Family Foundation health insurance coverage trends
  • HHS ASPE health care price transparency hospital
  • State health department uninsured rate by state

Suggested sources: CMS.gov, KFF.org, HHS.gov/ASPE

3. Public Education Reform

Constitutional anchor: State constitutions; 10th Amendment
Search tags for evidence:

  • NCES National Center for Education Statistics NAEP scores state
  • state school board meeting minutes curriculum transparency
  • National Assessment of Educational Progress reading math trends
  • state department of education per pupil spending

Suggested sources: NCES.ed.gov, state DOE websites

4. Justice Reform

Constitutional anchor: 5th, 6th, 8th, 14th Amendments Due Process, Equal Protection
Search tags for evidence:

  • Bureau of Justice Statistics incarceration rates state trends
  • DOJ Office of Community Oriented Policing Services use of force data
  • Sentencing Project state sentencing laws
  • state court public defender caseload statistics

Suggested sources: BJS.ojp.gov, DOJ.gov, state judiciary reports

5. Political Term Limits

Constitutional anchor: Art. I Sec. 2,3; Art. II Sec.1; Art. V amendment process
Search tags for evidence:

  • Congressional Research Service term limits Congress constitutional amendment
  • National Conference of State Legislatures state legislative term limits
  • Federal Election Commission incumbency reelection rates

Suggested sources: CRS Reports via Congress.gov, NCSL.org

6. Tax Relief

Constitutional anchor: Art. I Sec. 8 taxing power; 16th Amendment
Search tags for evidence:

  • IRS Statistics of Income individual tax returns
  • Tax Foundation state and local tax burden by state
  • Congressional Budget Office federal revenue outlays tax expenditure
  • Census Bureau Average Annual Social and Economic Supplements

Suggested sources: IRS.gov, TaxFoundation.org, CBO.gov

7. National Food and Agriculture Security

Constitutional anchor: Art. I Sec. 8 Commerce Clause
Search tags for evidence:

  • USDA Economic Research Service farm income food prices
  • USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service crop production
  • USDA Food Security in the U.S. Current Population Survey
  • Congressional Research Service food supply chain resilience

Suggested sources: USDA.gov/ERS, NASS.gov

8. Pharmaceutical Pricing and Profit Limits

Constitutional anchor: Commerce Clause; federal spending authority
Search tags for evidence:

  • CMS Medicare Part D drug spending
  • FDA drug approval timelines generic competition
  • ASPE drug price transparency state laws
  • KFF prescription drug price increases

Suggested sources: CMS.gov, FDA.gov, HHS.gov/ASPE

9. Bureaucratic Abuse and Overreach

Constitutional anchor: Separation of Powers Art. I, II, III; Administrative Procedure Act
Search tags for evidence:

  • Administrative Conference of the United States regulatory impact analysis
  • Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs regulatory agenda
  • Government Accountability Office agency oversight reports
  • Supreme Court major questions doctrine case law

Suggested sources: reginfo.gov, GAO.gov, supremecourt.gov

10. Immigration Systems

Constitutional anchor: Art. I Sec. 8 naturalization and immigration power; 5th/14th Amendment due process
Search tags for evidence:

  • DHS Yearbook of Immigration Statistics legal permanent residents
  • Census Bureau American Community Survey foreign-born population
  • DOJ Executive Office for Immigration Review immigration court backlog
  • Congressional Research Service immigration enforcement state cooperation

Suggested sources: DHS.gov/immigration-statistics, Census.gov/ACS, EOIR.justice.gov

11. Labor Institutions and Accountable Worker Representation

Constitutional and statutory context: First Amendment speech, peaceful assembly and petition rights; NLRA Section 7 rights for covered workers; LMRDA member rights; federal and state workplace safety laws.
Search tags for evidence:

  • NLRB Section 7 collective bargaining employee coverage exclusions
  • DOL OLMS LMRDA union financial reports elections member rights
  • OSHA worker safety enforcement state plan data
  • Apprenticeship.gov registered apprenticeship outcomes program standards

Suggested sources: National Labor Relations Board, Department of Labor OLMS, OSHA, Apprenticeship.gov.

12. Americans with Disabilities and Equal Civic Participation

Constitutional and statutory context: Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment due process and equal protection principles; ADA Titles I, II and III; Sections 503 and 504 of the Rehabilitation Act where applicable.
Search tags for evidence:

  • ADA.gov disability rights Title II services public accommodations
  • EEOC ADA reasonable accommodation employment guidance
  • DOJ accessible voting and polling places disability
  • DOJ Title II web accessibility rule current deadlines WCAG
  • ACL centers for independent living community participation

Suggested sources: ADA.gov, EEOC, DOJ voting guidance, HHS Section 504, Administration for Community Living.


How to use this research guide

Use the suggested search terms to locate original reports and datasets. Record the publication date, relevant context, and direct source link before citing a claim. Useful places to begin include:

  1. Primary government data: .gov domains
  2. Non-partisan research: Congressional Research Service, GAO, CBO, BLS, Census, USDA, CMS
  3. Peer-reviewed academic studies

Every substantive proposal should cite the specific evidence supporting it, identify material uncertainties, and distinguish the Coalition's recommendations from settled constitutional or statutory requirements.

Evidence into practice

Research worksheets for the ten focus areas

Use these worksheets to test a claim, not assume a conclusion. They expand the Evidence Appendix into specific measures, comparison fields, and citation records. All bracketed fields are unfilled placeholders, not research findings.

Download the blank research workbook (CSV)

Open the CSV in a spreadsheet to enter and save your work, or print this page and write on the worksheets. This page does not collect or save responses.

Before you start

  • Define the question: select a jurisdiction, population, baseline period and comparison period. Record your working claim separately from the evidence.
  • Keep comparisons consistent: record units, denominators, inflation adjustments, survey uncertainty and revisions. Mark unavailable data as unavailable, with a reason; never substitute zero.
  • Complete the citation: record the producer, exact title, dataset/table/series, release or revision date, direct URL, page/section and retrieval date. A source's homepage is not a citation to a finding.
  • Distinguish source types: KFF, NCSL and the Tax Foundation are not government agencies. Label their surveys, summaries or models accordingly. When using FRED, identify the original data producer and series.
  • Check legal claims separately: the Evidence Appendix is a research starting point, not a legal opinion. Verify jurisdiction, current law, controlling decisions and the status of proposals with qualified review.
  • Look for contrary evidence: record uncertainty, alternative explanations and what would change your conclusion. Avoid personal health, student, court-party or immigration records; use public aggregate data.

Researcher: [name]   Review date: [date]   Version: [version]

1. The Economy and Affordability

Research question: Which essential costs changed relative to household income in the selected place and period?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 1: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
CPI-U annual change Unit: Percent Use the same CPI-U series and seasonal-adjustment basis. Distinguish annual-average change from a December-to-December change; record the calculation.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ECO-01

BLS CPI; FRED for series discovery (cite the original producer)

Government statistics; aggregator for discovery

Median gross rent as a share of household income Unit: Percent Identify renter-occupied households and exclusions; use a published median or describe the calculation. Do not substitute the share of renters above a cost-burden threshold.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ECO-02

Census ACS housing tables; Household Pulse for supplemental context

Government survey

Real median household income Unit: Constant dollars Specify inflation base year and household definition. Keep ACS and CPS ASEC series separate; record margins of error or confidence intervals.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ECO-03

Census household income tables; CBO distribution reports

Government survey or analysis

Beige Book consumer spending and affordability observations Unit: Qualitative excerpts Record district and release date; include contrasting observations. This is qualitative reporting, not a representative consumer sentiment index.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ECO-04

Federal Reserve Beige Book

Government qualitative report

Citation record 1: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
ECO-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

ECO-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

ECO-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

ECO-04

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

2. Health and Healthcare

Research question: Which coverage gaps and household healthcare costs affect access, and which populations are most affected?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 2: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
National health expenditure per capita Unit: Dollars per person Specify calendar year and nominal or constant dollars. Total expenditure is not the same as a household's out-of-pocket cost.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

HEA-01

CMS National Health Expenditure Accounts

Government statistics

Uninsured rate by age group Unit: Percent of selected population Use consistent age bands and coverage definitions. Keep point-in-time estimates separate from full-year uninsured estimates; report uncertainty.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

HEA-02

Census ACS or CPS ASEC; state health departments; KFF for context

Government survey; secondary research for context

Employer-plan deductible Unit: Dollars per covered worker Specify single or family coverage, mean or median, and whether workers without a deductible are included. Do not equate deductible with total annual spending.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

HEA-03

KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey

Independent survey; not a government source

Price-transparency compliance Unit: Percent and numerator/denominator Define the rule, jurisdiction, review date, sampled providers and compliance test. If no comparable compliance measure exists, record that rather than assume zero.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

HEA-04

CMS hospital price transparency; HHS ASPE; state health department reports

Government administrative records or analysis

Citation record 2: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
HEA-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

HEA-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

HEA-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

HEA-04

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

3. Public Education Reform

Research question: How do learning outcomes and school resources compare across districts and student groups over time?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 3: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
NAEP reading and mathematics scores Unit: Scale score Separate grade 4 and grade 8, subject, year and student group. Use the same assessment scale; record sampling uncertainty and changes in participation.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

EDU-01

NCES National Assessment of Educational Progress

Government assessment

Per-pupil expenditure Unit: Dollars per pupil Distinguish current expenditure from total expenditure; specify fiscal year, enrollment denominator, inflation adjustment and included funding sources.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

EDU-02

NCES finance tables; state education departments

Government finance statistics

High-school graduation rate Unit: Percent of adjusted cohort Identify cohort year and four-year or extended-year measure. Record transfers, exclusions and subgroup definitions; do not substitute a completion rate.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

EDU-03

NCES graduation tables; state education departments

Government administrative statistics

Curriculum-transparency policy and implementation Unit: Policy text and documented actions Record policy version, adoption date, access procedure and evidence of implementation. A policy's existence alone does not establish compliance or learning effects.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

EDU-04

State and district school-board policies and meeting minutes

Primary policy and meeting records

Citation record 3: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
EDU-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

EDU-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

EDU-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

EDU-04

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

4. Justice Reform

Research question: Where do justice outcomes or processing times differ, and what evidence explains those differences?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 4: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
Incarceration rate Unit: People per 100000 residents Separate prisons from local jails and sentenced populations from pretrial detention. Match custody date, jurisdiction and population denominator.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

JUS-01

Bureau of Justice Statistics incarceration reports

Government statistics

Case-processing time Unit: Days Specify case type, starting and ending events, median or mean, and whether pending cases are excluded. Compare like courts and reporting periods.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

JUS-02

State judiciary caseload and timeliness reports

Primary court administrative statistics

One-year post-release recidivism Unit: Percent of release cohort Define rearrest, reconviction or reincarceration; specify cohort, follow-up window and tracking coverage. Do not compare unlike recidivism definitions.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

JUS-03

BJS recidivism studies; state corrections reports

Government longitudinal or administrative study

Reported use-of-force incidents Unit: Count; rate only with a documented denominator Specify reportable force definition and agency reporting coverage. Separate non-reporting from zero incidents; examine whether reporting changes explain trends.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

JUS-04

DOJ use-of-force resources; participating agency and oversight reports

Government or primary oversight records

Citation record 4: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
JUS-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

JUS-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

JUS-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

JUS-04

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

5. Political Term Limits

Research question: What do term-limit rules and electoral records show, and what cannot be attributed to term limits alone?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 5: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
States with legislative term limits Unit: Count with jurisdiction list Record chamber, limit length, consecutive or lifetime basis, effective date and exceptions. Confirm summaries against current enacted state law.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

TER-01

NCSL term-limit summaries; state constitutions and legislative records

Secondary legislative summary; primary law for verification

Federal term-limit legal pathway Unit: Legal authority and status Record the precise proposition, CRS report version, constitutional provisions, controlling cases and status of any proposed amendment. Distinguish proposals from binding law.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

TER-02

CRS reports through Congress.gov; Article V and cited court opinions

Government legal analysis; primary legal authority

Incumbent reelection rate Unit: Percent of incumbents seeking reelection Separate House and Senate and primary/general elections. Define denominator and treatment of retirees, open seats and uncontested races; control for other explanations.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

TER-03

FEC election results; official state election returns

Government election records; researcher calculation

Citation record 5: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
TER-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

TER-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

TER-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

6. Tax Relief

Research question: How are tax burdens and proposed relief distributed across households, and how would revenue change?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 6: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
Effective federal tax rate by income group Unit: Percent of defined income State included taxes, income definition, year and grouping. Do not treat marginal rates as effective rates or divide unlike IRS and CBO denominators.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

TAX-01

CBO household income and federal tax reports; IRS Statistics of Income

Government analysis or tax statistics

State and local tax burden Unit: Percent of defined income Specify residence or collection basis, included taxes and incidence assumptions. Label modeled estimates and compare them with official revenue totals where possible.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

TAX-02

Tax Foundation methodology and estimates; state revenue records; Census finance data

Secondary model; government records for comparison

Federal tax expenditure estimates Unit: Dollars over stated fiscal period Name each provision and tax baseline; record interactions and uncertainty. Do not assume separate estimates can be summed or equal repeal revenue.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

TAX-03

CBO tax expenditure analysis and cited official estimates

Government budget analysis

Citation record 6: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
TAX-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

TAX-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

TAX-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

7. National Food and Agriculture Security

Research question: Which production, household food-access and supply risks are documented in the selected period?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 7: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
U.S. net farm income Unit: Dollars Identify nominal or constant dollars and forecast or realized estimate. Separate aggregate sector income from the distribution across farms.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

AGR-01

USDA Economic Research Service farm income data

Government statistics or forecast

Food price change Unit: Percent Specify food-at-home or food-away-from-home series, period and calculation. Record whether the result is observed or forecast.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

AGR-02

USDA ERS Food Price Outlook; underlying BLS CPI series

Government statistics or forecast

U.S. share of world corn and soybean production Unit: Percent of production volume Keep commodities separate and align marketing years, units and revision dates for U.S. and world totals. Use a world denominator from a documented USDA series.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

AGR-03

USDA NASS crop production; USDA world production tables

Government crop statistics; researcher calculation

Household food insecurity prevalence Unit: Percent of households Keep households and persons distinct; specify food insecurity or very low food security, survey period and subgroup. Record sampling uncertainty.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

AGR-04

USDA ERS Household Food Security in the United States; CPS supplement

Government survey analysis

Citation record 7: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
AGR-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

AGR-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

AGR-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

AGR-04

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

8. Pharmaceutical Pricing and Profit Limits

Research question: Which medicine costs and competition measures are documented, and what additional evidence would a pricing proposal require?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 8: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
Medicare Part D spending per beneficiary Unit: Dollars per defined beneficiary Specify covered drugs, year and beneficiary denominator; document rebate treatment. Gross program spending is neither a drug's net price nor manufacturer profit.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

PHA-01

CMS Medicare Part D drug spending data; HHS ASPE analyses

Government administrative data or analysis

Price change for a defined set of 50 brand drugs Unit: Percent Define the selection rule before analysis, exact products and doses, list or net price, period and weighting. Do not imply this basket represents every medicine.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

PHA-02

HHS ASPE prescription drug price reports; KFF analyses and underlying sources

Government or secondary analysis

Generic drug approvals Unit: Approvals per year Distinguish final, tentative and first-generic approvals. Approvals do not establish actual market entry, supply, savings or profitability; verify those separately.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

PHA-03

FDA generic drug approval reports

Government regulatory records

Citation record 8: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
PHA-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

PHA-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

PHA-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Profit-limit proposals: price changes and program spending do not establish profit margins. Any such proposal needs separately sourced revenue/cost evidence, a defined accounting basis, legal analysis and assessment of possible effects on supply and access.

Back to worksheet index

9. Bureaucratic Abuse and Overreach

Research question: Which specific agency actions raise a documented legal or administrative concern, and what do authoritative reviews conclude?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 9: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
Major federal rules issued Unit: Count under a stated definition Specify major-rule definition, fiscal/calendar year and final versus proposed rules. Counts alone do not demonstrate burden, illegality or abuse.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ADM-01

OIRA regulatory records at Reginfo.gov; GAO major-rule reports

Government regulatory records

GAO High-Risk List findings Unit: Risk areas and cited findings Record report date, risk area, specific deficiency and agency response. Risk areas are not simply an agency count or a finding of misconduct.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ADM-02

GAO High-Risk Series and follow-up reports

Government oversight analysis

Federal Register page volume Unit: Pages per year Document included material and counting method. Page volume is an administrative output measure, not a measure of regulatory costs or abuse.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ADM-03

Federal Register annual statistics; OIRA records for context

Government publication statistics

Administrative-law decisions Unit: Case holding and procedural status Record court, docket, date, agency action, majority holding, remedy and later history. Separate binding holdings from dicta and dissent; seek qualified legal review.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

ADM-04

Supreme Court opinions; GAO and Administrative Conference analyses

Primary legal authority; government analysis

Citation record 9: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
ADM-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

ADM-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

ADM-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

ADM-04

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

10. Immigration Systems

Research question: What do admission, population, case-processing and enforcement measures show when their definitions are kept separate?

Working claim: [claim to test]   Jurisdiction / population: [scope]   Period: [baseline and comparison]

Data worksheet 10: measures and comparisons
Measure and checksYour comparison dataSource lead and citation ID
People granted lawful permanent residence Unit: Persons per fiscal year Separate new arrivals and adjustments of status. Grants are a flow, not the stock of all permanent residents; record revisions.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

IMM-01

DHS immigration statistics yearbooks and tables

Government administrative statistics

Foreign-born population share by state Unit: Percent of resident population Use a consistent ACS one-year or five-year product and record margins of error. Foreign-born does not mean undocumented or noncitizen.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

IMM-02

Census American Community Survey

Government survey

Immigration court pending caseload Unit: Cases at a stated date Distinguish pending stock from new filings and completions; identify courts, case types and reporting revisions. Add processing-time evidence before drawing delay conclusions.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

IMM-03

DOJ Executive Office for Immigration Review statistical reports

Government court administrative statistics

Immigration enforcement removals Unit: Recorded events or persons as defined Record fiscal year, agency and definition; distinguish removals, returns and other actions. Do not sum overlapping agency series or assume events are unique people.

Baseline: [period] / [value or finding]

Comparison: [period] / [value or finding]

Scope: [geography, population and denominator]

IMM-04

DHS immigration enforcement statistics; CRS for definitional context

Government administrative statistics or analysis

Citation record 10: replace source leads with exact references
Citation IDPublication and datasetLocation and retrieval
IMM-01

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

IMM-02

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

IMM-03

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

IMM-04

[producer / author, exact publication title, dataset, table, series or case identifier]

Released / revised: [date]

[direct source URL]

[page, section or table location]

Retrieved: [date]

Assessment and review

Finding: [supported / mixed / not supported / insufficient evidence; explain and cite the measure IDs]

Limitations and counterevidence: [missing data, uncertainty, reporting changes, other explanations and contrary sources]

Legal and policy check: [exact authority, jurisdiction, current status, date checked and reviewer]

Options and trade-offs: [possible actions, costs, affected groups, responsible body, alternatives and a follow-up measure]

Reviewer / date / next review: [name and dates]

Back to worksheet index

Comments on Coalition Mission

Remember to keep it civilized...
Please login to comment